ex_pseudonymous328: (Default)
Pseudonymous ([personal profile] ex_pseudonymous328) wrote in [community profile] readingtheclassics2009-06-03 06:16 am

Dorian Gray Discussion - Wit and Realism

I've gotten a couple of chapters in to Dorian Gray and I am wondering what everyone thinks about Wilde's renowned wit. 

As an aside, I have been on a realism kick in books lately.  I have actively been searching out novels where the characters (especially women) are portrayed as normal people instead of brilliant, beautiful, special snowflakes whom every male character wants to have sex with.  The alternative seems to be where women are unattractive as a  plot point.  Still not reality and rather annoying.

Back to Dorian Gray.  Oscar Wilde is famous for being clever and witty, whereas us normal people are not that damn insightful or amusing. In reading the first few chapters, every character had a smart comeback or observation for everything.  The part of me that has been searching for realism rolled my eyes and thought how clever, Oscar. Aren't you something?  

Can a writer be too witty for his or her own good? 

How important is realism to you enjoying a novel?

What other thoughts do you have on The Picture of Dorian Gray?

         
cesy: "Cesy" - An old-fashioned quill and ink (Default)

Wit and Realism

[personal profile] cesy 2009-06-03 11:58 am (UTC)(link)
I remember noticing this to a certain extent last time I read The Importance of Being Earnest. The wittiness isn't realistic, but it does make it easier and more fun to read provided you're not looking for realism in that area.